To Buddy's friend,
If I had done research like you when I was 13 (and if it had been available...was there even an internet back then?) then my childhood dog would have lived his life fully and happily, and not all alone in our back yard with no human contact except when my dad put his food dish out for him.
When I first got my dog over two years ago (he was 8 months old) I went nuts doing research and watching dog shows and reading books. Luckily all the books I got were the right ones, and any bad info I found was just on the internet or on TV - and by that I mean I didn't have to waste money on rubbish books. The downside is that I found the bad info to begin with. There is likely more bad info out there than good. I can assure you that THIS forum is the SAFEST place for you to do research. The folks here will tell you the right books to read, the right websites to visit, and the right methods to use. If anyone here accidentally gives you the wrong info, you'll get the correct info FAST. People here are on the ball.
Now when I say the "right" info, I mean "safe and effective." Lots of methods will work for sure, but many of them will damage your relationship with your dog.
I subscribed to the alpha stuff very briefly. Oh yes, I did all of the following:
- pretended to eat out of my dog's bowl
- made him wait at the door to let me walk through first
- made him get up to move so I could walk by even if he was lying down comfortably and there was plenty of room to walk around him
- took his bone from him and then gave it back in order to prove to him that it was mine and I was just allowing him to play with it
- alpha rolled him when he nipped at someone as a fear response
And so much more!
So what did that accomplish? I succeeded in getting my dog to:
- snap at my hands
- growl when I approached while he played with a toy
- cower when I stood near him
- flinch when I reached for him (even if it was just to pet him)
AND I made all his fear issues ten times worse. He started out only fearing cats and large, strange objects on the street, then it became people and other dogs too! Fun right?
So what did I do? I started over. I got all the right info from people that I trusted (people here) and authors I trusted (Patricia McConnell, Karen Pryor, Ali Brown, Jean Donaldson - remember those names).
Since I've dumped that way of thinking and started using safe, effective, positive methods on my dog, I have the following from him:
- polite when food is around - he'll sit for meals and lie at our feet while we eat, no nosing around
- plays with his toys and doesn't take notice of me when I walk by
- very attentive during training sessions
- walks 99% perfectly on leash
- "checks in" during walks by looking up at me frequently
- still flinches when I reach for him too fast (how this breaks my heart) but accepts affection now
I'm telling you all this because I don't want you to go down the same road I did, not any further than you already have. So from now on, I ask that you think of things a different way. Don't "correct" your dog - teach him what you want from him and be patient as he learns. You are not alpha, you are not a pack leader. You are his TEACHER.
So, moving forward...
Your recall issue from your original post... read these:
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=6555
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=6364
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=5962
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4310
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=5452
You'll see it's the same advice over and over, but the solution really is universal. Sounds like you have a big yard, yes? So you have lots of room to practice.
I don't know if anyone took note of this comment:
Not a big problem, but sometimes he whines a lot when we're not outside with him (he stays on a long leash on the front porch). I suppose just simply correcting him everytime he whines might work.
Don't correct him. Don't make him be out there alone. Go out and interact with him or bring him inside. He needs to be with his family. Please rethink the outdoor dog thing. You're worried about shedding? Brush him every day. It's a great bonding experience for both of you in addition to helping with the shedding issue.
You sound like you have a lovely dog with a few issues you need to work through. And you're having a rough time right now with everything your family is going through (I can relate to more from that list of things going on than I care to recall right now). Your dog will help you through all of the stress your family is going through. Pets are wonderful that way. So make sure you do the same for him, make sure that you deserve the unconditional love he's giving you.
Good luck. Please stick around. You don't even know the possibilities of what you can do for your dog once you're here.
PS to Nettle. Please explain why you wouldn't recommend Dunbar now? I have not read his books, just articles from the dogstardaily website. I'm curious.