Hi, and two questions.

First-time users can introduce themselves to the Positively community here.

Moderators: emmabeth, BoardHost

Post Reply
Nebula
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Apr 18, 2013 7:07 am

Hi, and two questions.

Post by Nebula »

Hi!
I've just joined, as you can see, and am eager to learn more about dog training.

However I have just two questions. I have recently researched into the dominance technique, and I did previously to use it, but now I prefer positive training (it seems so much more effective!)

My first question is: do our dogs need leadership from us, and if so in what ways?

And my second: Do dogs have hierarchies in the way that the dominance theory says, or is it completely different? I understand that they are not on a quest for dominance or whatever but I'm a little unsure on this.

Thanks for taking time to read this,

~Nebula
JudyN
Posts: 7018
Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2011 1:20 pm
Location: Dorset, UK
Contact:

Re: Hi, and two questions.

Post by JudyN »

Hi, and welcome to the forum :D Your dog looks lovely - what sort is he/she?

'Leadership': it's all about vocabulary, isn't it? Some people think that leadership means that your dog should be utterly obedient, just because you say so. I'd say yes, a dog does need you to be a leader, but more in the sense of a guide. Someone you respect because you trust them totally. Think of a team where someone is given the position of 'team leader' just so you don't spend all your time discussing what to do and never getting anything done.

So on a walk, my dog can tell me which direction he would like to go in and I may choose to listen to him and indulge him. But if I want to go the other way (usually because he wants to go where the deer are) I expect him to follow me with reasonable good grace.

Where it gets interesting is when he won't follow me - and that's when we have to use our superior brains, not force, or intimidation, either to avoid the situation or train so that going where we want to go becomes a habit and they see it as a good option.

As for hierarchies in dogs - I think they tend to be contextual, and are much more fluid than people suppose. Where they exist, it's for convenience, to avoid conflict. Just as in some situations I will follow my husband's lead and in others, he will follow mine.
Jasper, lurcher, born December 2009
Nebula
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Apr 18, 2013 7:07 am

Re: Hi, and two questions.

Post by Nebula »

Oh, that dog is just an American Pit Bull terrier off Google - I don't have any pictures of my own dog, unfortunately, but he's a black Labrador mix.

That makes sense; thank you for the explanation! I know two dogs that live together, and now that I think about it, it's like you said - who is in charge changes in different situations. Anyway, thanks again!
Post Reply