Can Spaying Make Dog Behavior Worse?

On an episode of “It’s Me or the Dog,” Victoria Stilwell tackled the problem of a bull terrier that exhibited mounting behavior. The first solution was to send the dog for a time-out when he mounted. However, the mounting was so severe that the trainer finally recommended neutering, which solved the problem. This case raises two questions: What other behavioral issues can neutering help address, and what is the rate of success?

In general, it would be expected that spaying or neutering most likely affects sexually dimorphic behaviors — those that are more characteristic for one gender or the other. This is exactly what a 1997 study conducted by researchers at the University of California, Davis, Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital found.

Misbehaving Male Dogs

This study evaluated how neutering adult male dogs affected such problem behaviors as urine marking in the house, mounting, roaming, fear of inanimate stimuli as well as aggression toward family members, strangers, household dogs, unfamiliar dogs and human territorial intruders.

Fifty-seven dogs that had exhibited one or more of these problems before being castrated at 2 to 7 years of age were included in the study.
Follow-up revealed that castration was most effective at reducing:

urine marking
mounting
roaming

The decrease was marked.

These behaviors decreased by 90% in 40% of the study dogs
And decreased by 50% in the remaining 60% of the study dogs

No relationship existed between the effect of neutering and the age of the dog or duration of the problem behavior before castration.

Neutering also affected aggression toward canine and human family members but to a lesser extent and in fewer dogs, with 25% of the study dogs improving by more than 50%.

Surprisingly, 10% to 15% of dogs showed less aggression toward unfamiliar dogs and territorial intruders. Therefore, neutering can likely provide marked improvement for many dogs that are exhibiting marking, roaming or mounting behavior and may offer some improvement in dogs that are aggressive toward people and other dogs. Neutering seems to be less successful in reducing other types of aggression, although improvement is possible.

Misbehaving Male Cats

For cats, the story may be even more promising. “Regarding behaviors that are more specific to male animals, castration seems to be more effective [in modifying behavior problems] in cats than in dogs,” says Melissa Bain, DVM, assistant professor of clinical animal behavior at UC Davis.

A study conducted at UC Davis in the 1990s found that in 90% of male cats, castration greatly reduces or eliminates
•    urine spraying
•    roaming
•    fighting with neighborhood males

Fifty percent of the cats showed a dramatic decrease (80% decrease) in the spraying, roaming and fighting in the first week, although the remaining study cats demonstrated a more gradual decline.

 

For Females the Effects May be Different

The study results for male dogs and cats make the course of action clear. But for female dogs, the findings on the effects of spaying on behavior were unexpected.

According to Katherine Houpt, VMD, PhD, DACVB, director of the Animal Behavior Clinic at Cornell University Hospital for Animals, spaying may actually contribute to behavioral problems. In a cooperative study with the Institute of Animal Medicine at Gyeongsang National University in Korea, Houpt and her colleagues found that ovariohysterectomy (spay) in healthy German Shepherds bred as working dogs led to increased reactivity.

In the study, 14 healthy German Shepherd bitches at the Korean Air Force Dog Training Center were studied. Half of the study dogs were spayed at 5 to 10 months of age, and the other half were intact. The dogs were littermates and were split equally into both groups to control for genetics. The dogs all lived in the same kennel environment and received similar handling. Their behavioral reactions were tested at 4 and 5 months after surgery.

Each dog was tested separately in its outdoor kennel while the rest of the dogs remained indoors. An unfamiliar human with an unknown dog walked within 1 meter of the target dog’s kennel, and the kenneled German Shepherd’s response was recorded.

In each of four different recordings for each dog, researchers recorded
•    barking or growling
•    lunging
•    jumping
•    snapping
•    head high
•    ears forward
•    eyes staring
•    lips lifting or curling.

Dogs were scored as follows
•    Score of 3 if they exhibited all 10 behaviors
•    Score of 2 if they exhibited 7 of 10 behaviors
•    Score of 1 if they exhibited 5 of 10 behaviors
•    Score of 0 if they exhibited less than 4 of the behaviors

“Ideally we would have scored the dogs before they were spayed, too,” says Houpt. “Regardless, the results were dramatic. Dogs that had been spayed were significantly more reactive, with most receiving scores of 2 and 3, whereas the unspayed littermates received reactivity scores of 1.”

These scores decreased in two of the seven experimental dogs on repeat testing, but by the final testing phase, five of the seven dogs still received a score of 2 or higher.

Houpt emphasizes that military dogs would be expected to exhibit more aggressive behaviors and such behavior on command may be desirable. These dogs would not, however, be appropriate as pet or guide dogs or for pet therapy. Although the study was small, Houpt suggests that veterinarians should consider performing a hysterectomy rather than an ovariohysterectomy for preventive health reasons in aggressive pet female dogs.

Such decisions on whether to perform surgery or not should be made with all the facts in hand since failure to remove the ovaries can increase the incidence of mammary cancer. Female dogs spayed after their second heat have a 26% higher risk of developing mammary cancer than those spayed before their first heat.

“Of course, theoretically, the real cure would be to spay and then give progestins,” Houpt added. “This was done years ago and worked well until the dogs became diabetic and had increased appetites. Sometimes you could cure the territorial aggression, but then they became food-aggressive. It is not something we recommend now.”

References

1. Neilson JC, Eckstein RA, Hart BL. Effects of castration on problem behaviors in male dogs with reference to age and duration of behavior. JAVMA 1997;211(2):180-183.

2. Hart BL, Eckstein RA. The role of gonadal hormones in the occurrence of objectionable behaviours in dogs and cats. Appl Anim Behav Sci 1997;52:331-344.

3. Im HH, Yeon SC, Houpt KA, et al. Effects of ovariohysterectomy on reactivity in German shepherd dogs. Vet J 2006;172(1):154-159.

The original version of this article originally appeared in Veterinary Forum in November 2008.


tweet it post it Share It Plus It Print It
authorname

Positively Expert: Sophia Yin

Dr. Yin is an internationally-acclaimed veterinarian and applied animal behaviorist who lectures and teaches workshops to dog trainers, shelter workers, and veterinary staff, and is the author of three books including a veterinary textbook and DVD set on behavior. Her "pet-friendly" techniques have set the standard of care for veterinarians.


JOIN THE CONVERSATION
  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments()

  • Tim Dunton

    This begs the question at what age is the best time to Neuter. I notice the male dogs were between 2 and 7 where as the female dogs were 5 to 10 months. I've heard if you neuter too early especially in male dogs that there is a problem with increased growth whereby the testosterone acts as a growth inhibitor and slow the growth down to a normal level, if you neuter too early then the dog has physical problems iwhere the body grows too big before the dogs have had time to catch up. I am just wondering in the case of the females were they spayed too early, which begs the question does oestrogen have the same effect on growth etc, and by spaying too early you are stopping vital hormones from being produced.

    kind regards

    Tim Dunton

  • Elena

    Estrogens are really powerful hormones that are present in both males and females and have a huge impact on growth and puberty. The best article I read while I was deciding when to spay my puppy (who is now 13 months and still intact, because I'm so freaked out) is this: http://www.caninesports.com/EarlySpayConsiderations.pdf Removing the organs that produce the sex hormones in males and females cause them to grow disproportionately and puts them at risk for ligament injury. The article is about agility dogs, but frankly, I do not want my 80 pound dog to tear her ACL and not be able to go hiking with me.

  • Pingback: All of this talk about spaying and neutering?? - Page 2 - YorkieTalk.com Forums - Yorkshire Terrier Community()

  • Pingback: when do they come home after spaying - YorkieTalk.com Forums - Yorkshire Terrier Community()

Positively Dog Training Episode 703

What’s the real reason so many people won’t adopt rescue dogs, and what happens when fosters or adoptions don’t go well?...

Positively Podcast 702

How to be prepared for natural disasters with your pet, what happens to dogs rescued from dogfighting rings, how to help your dog...

Positively Dog Training Episode 701

Victoria and Holly reconnect after a few months away and discuss how to recognize signs of pain in your older dog, keys to curbing...

find a vspdt trainer
Schedule a consultation via skype or phone