Private Drug-Sniffing Dogs: A Good or Bad Idea?
Pat Greenhouse/Boston Globe via Getty Images
Drug-sniffing dogs are no longer limited to law enforcement. The industry is being privatized by individual trainers and their dogs, who search the homes of people who feel they have a family member that may be using illegal drugs.
These businesses utilize the same techniques used by law enforcement, but are not legally obligated to report what they find.
Tom Robichaud, owner of Discreet Intervention, says that in extreme cases (such as finding a meth lab or a large amount of a narcotic) he will be morally compelled to alert the police.
In typical cases, if the dog alerts on a small amount of anarcotic, full discretion is given to the parents on whether or not they want to involve the police. As a result, these private drug-sniffing businesses are exploding.
While the law protects citizens against unwarranted police searches, it has not yet been amended to prevent unwanted searches by nosy neighbors.
Law enforcement officials are concerned that these types of private investigations could accidentally interfere with ongoing police investigations, putting both officers and the dog handler in a potentially dangerous situation.
Beyond that, private drug-sniffing dogs are not required to complete the evaluations and certifications that law enforcement dogs and handlers do. Therefore, the evidence they find may not be admissible in court.
What are your thoughts on private drug-sniffing dogs? Leave your comments below.
2 thoughts on “Private Drug-Sniffing Dogs: A Good or Bad Idea?”
Leave a Reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Episode 829 - Advocating for Animals with Peter Egan
Advocating for Animals – Victoria and Holly are joined by actor and animal activist, Peter Egan to discuss dogs, moon bears and...
Episode 828 - A Fresh Take on the Debate About Shock Collars
Victoria is joined by dog behaviour expert and a driving force behind the UK Dog Behaviour & Training Charter Andrew Hale to...
Episode 827 - How to Transition Dogs from Crisis into Care
The rescue of 180 Chihuahuas sparks a larger conversation on how to transition dogs from crisis situations into homes.
What I don't like about this: Where is the line drawn between an illegal search and an allowable search? This article speaks to parents with children, but does that mean they can hire a search of their 19 year old son's dorm room? And if the dog alerts to "drugs" that don't belong to the client's child, what then? Personally I think if a parent needs to bring a drug sniffing dog into their teenager's bedroom, there are more problems than the potential substance abuse. I know when I was accused of being an addict as a teenager (when really I was only dealing with depression) having my room searched was just twisting the knife in an already open and oozing wound. But a drug dog on top of it? In my case, at least, this would have made our situation much worse.
Tie Dye’s Momma, I would like to take the time to address
your concerns and maybe in some ways agree with you. I operate a company which
does just what has been described here. Private residential searches are a very
small portion of my business as we focus on Schools, Businesses and have a
federal facility as a staple client. When I founded Specialized K9 detection
service for this federal facility, I found no one around us who would provide
assistance in this area. As a retired Police school resource officer and DARE
instructor, my background in assisting families in crisis made this a perfect
fit for us. I have been dealing with residential clients in need of assistance
with heroin addiction which has become more than an epidemic in New York. That
said, you are correct that if a parent goes to these lengths there is a much
deeper problem, and all my clients have said they are at the end of their rope
and didn’t know where else to turn. As far as anything being illegal, a
homeowner has the ability to approve such a search including all areas of the
home. There would be exceptions such as a private apartment attached to the
house or similar situations that I would take into consideration before
accepting a job. That should answer the dorm room statement where we could not
provide that service. That said, any university could have a dog walk the hallways
of dorms, privately or through law enforcement.
You are also right about the trust issue and there are arguments
on both sides that can be compelling. From my perspective, having my experience
in dealing with families is a bonus as I am able to do so much more than just
come in and have my dogs sniff around. I maintain many great contacts for assistance
referrals which may also help to provide answers or solutions. While I would
not always recommend a K9’s intervention, I do find it is a valuable tool under
the right circumstances.